The Female Narrative of War in Harras written by Nasim Marashi and Beirut Blues Written by Hannan al-Sheikh

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 M.A. student in comparative literature, Department of Persian Language and Literature, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, IKIU, Qazvin, Iran

2 Author, Assistant Professor, Department of Persian Language and Literature, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, IKIU, Qazvin, Iran.

10.22126/jccl.2024.9455.2530

Abstract

"Women's Writing" is a significant approach in feminist criticism. This approach is a distinct female narrative element of male writing, which represents the difference in the application of emotional lexis, more use of colored phrases, oaths, principles of procrastination, losers and syntactic characteristics such as the use of prayer sentences (curses and prayers), Descriptive sentences, questional sentences appear in the form of self-esteem, and, finally, short and simplified sentences. Contents and issues such as historical affliction of self-confidence, and misandry, self-discovery, life concerns and overcoming romantic love are also from the feminine content. Nasim Marashi in Haras and Hanan al-Sheikh (the Lebanese female writer) in Beirut Blues, have different perspectives over war and human relations in the war condition and, in particular, position of women in the family and society. Using a descriptive-analytical method and a comparative approach of the female narrative of war, the effect of war on women's lives and their gender restrictions in the patriarchal society is described in this study and, furthermore, it was shown that female writers emphasized the terrible consequences of the war and expressed its affection and devotion based on their female spiritualities. They have never praised war, though. Both writers, by using emotional interpretations, of colored phrases, oaths and the emotional and praying sentences, and the simplicity and short sentences have considered contents such as historical affliction of self-confidence, and misandry, self-discovery, life concerns & overcoming of romantic love. 
Introduction:
Women writers sometimes have different and even opposite views from men on various topics. One of the mentioned differences is the one between female and male narratives of war. Iran and Lebanon are among the countries that have faced domestic and foreign wars. War and its consequences created a special literary genre that was significantly different from the literature before the war. These changes are seen in the structure, language, and content of the literature. The literature of sacred defense is about writings and works that are related to the imposed war and its issues, and their main themes are war and its aftermath, also known as “resistance literature.” Lebanese literature, from a country that went through years of civil war and turmoil, has also become completely connected to war.
Method:
This research discusses the works of two female writers who have explored the theme of war in their fiction: Nasim Marashi and Hanan al-Shaykh. Marashi's novel Haras tells the story of a family whose life and destiny were affected by the eight-year long war between Iran and Iraq and its aftermath. Hanan al-Shaykh, in her novel Beirut Blues, portrays Lebanon in the civil war and the inner struggles of a patriotic character who has to choose between leaving or staying in her homeland. She shows the horrors of war, violence, exile, and destruction. Both novels present a feminine perspective on war, and the two writers have given an account full of worry and anxiety but also tinged with nostalgic love and emotion, which is remarkable. Marashi has a smooth and natural writing style, and she chooses the themes of her stories from people's concerns and social problems. Her stories are not linear. She also keeps the reader interested with captivating suspense until the last pages of the book. In Haras, the characters have a feminine spirit, and the writer, by describing their feelings, has created an engaging narrative. Hanan al-Shaykh, a feminist writer in Arabic literature, has written stories that challenge injustice and oppression, especially against women. She expresses the feminine spirit, emotions, and feelings, and uses a language that is intimate and simple without compromising the subject for formality and dryness. This research is a descriptive-analytical and comparative study. It introduces the theoretical foundations of the research, which are the components of feminine writing style. It studies the novels Haras and Beirut Blues and examines the indicators of feminine narrative from the perspective of feminine writing at three levels: lexical, syntactical, and content. It analyzes the components of feminine narrative, such as the use of feminine emotional expressions, swear words, phrases that show reasoning and emphasis, sentences that apply or request something, questions that are used as soliloquies, sentences that are incomplete or simple, and contents that reflect historical resentment, forgetfulness, hatred of men, concern for life, romantic love, and self-discovery.
Results and Discussion:
The female characters in “Haras” want to pursue their individual rights. But in “Beirut Blues”, the female character tries to reach her lover or free the land from war. Women describe war and their emotional perspective, which is full of sadness, sacrifice, and grief. Haras and Beirut Blues show the features of feminine storytelling in the areas of lexis, expressions, words, emotional expressions, use of words for colors, phrases that show reasoning and emphasis, sentences that ask or beg for something, swear words, and how they make sentences. Most of the words used in both works are about family, women's issues, and feminine interests. These two works reflect the emotions and feelings of the female narrator. By using simple writing, descriptive details, and questions / appeals (prayer and curse), these writers have shown how their writing differs from masculine writing. Both writers have used a variety of words to express emotions and beauty. For example, both writers are careful when using colors. Both writers' works have emotional expressions that are common in women's speech, such as using small words, curses, and prayers, and phrases that show the speaker's passion, excitement, and feelings.
Many themes such as criticizing forgetfulness, dreaming and imagining, wishing, waiting, harted toward men, finding and exploring oneself, caring for life, and the dominance of romantic love, are the content features of feminine narrative. Haras has more examples of the main characters in the story using pleading sentences and swear words in their language, because the female characters have less self-confidence, while Beirut Blues shows more of the power of love. For both writers, family is the source and basis of life in the theme of caring for life. The writers mention the supportive role of men in the family. In the relationship of Asmahan, the narrator in Beirut Blues, has more examples of the theme of the dominance of romantic love. The female characters in both works try to find their identity and place in their own ways. Paying attention to home is also a noticeable topic and the women in both novels spend most of their time at home. Dreaming is also one of the concepts that the two writers use.
Conclusion:
In these novels, two women writers told stories of war from a feminine perspective. We found that both of them expressed their emotions and feelings clearly, using details, simple language, and questions and requests. They also used short sentences more often because they paid attention to small things. Their writing showed their passion, excitement, and feelings. In Haras, the character Rasool showed how men in a male-dominated society treated women as "the other" and did not value them as much as men in every aspect of his life, work, and family. Rasool preferred sons over daughters. Both novels also showed how women searched for themselves and their identity as women, but they did it in different ways. Both novels had themes of dreaming, imagining, and wanting a home and a family. The women in the stories used these themes to escape from the harsh reality of the world outside. The Lebanese novel focused more on the theme of romantic love, and the character Asmahan used her relationships with different people to overcome her doubts and find herself. Haras also had romance, but it was more influenced by society and the mood of the people.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Article Title [العربیة]

الروایة النسائیة عن الحرب فی کتاب هرس نسیم مرعشی و کتاب برید بیروت لحنان الشیخ

Abstract [العربیة]

تعتبر الکتابة النسائیة أحد المقاربات البارزة فی النقد النسوی الذی یعتبر روایات النسائیة مختلفة عن کتابات الرجال. یظهر هذا الاختلاف فی استخدام الکلمات العاطفیة، و الکلمات الملونة، و الکلمات القسمیة، و العبارات التعللیة، المشددات (المکثفات) و الخصائص النحویة مثل استخدام جمل الدعاء (اللعنة والدعاء)، و الجمل الوصفیة، و الجمل الاستفهامیة على شکل حدیث نفس، و الجمل القصیرة و الکتابة البسیطة. مواضیع مثل نسیان المرأة، و کراهیة الرجال، و البحث عن الذات، و الاهتمام بالحیاة، و سیطرة الحب الرومانسی هی أیضًا من بین محتوى المرأة. رسمت نسیم مرعشی فی کتاب هرس و حنان الشیخ، کاتبة لبنانیة، فی کتاب برید بیروت زوایا مختلفة لموقف المرأة فی الأسرة و المجتمع الذی مزقته الحرب. وفی البحث الحالی باستخدام المنهج الوصفی التحلیلی و المنهج المقارن وصفت روایة المرأة عن الحرب فی هاتین الروایتین وتأثیر الحرب على حیاة المرأة و قیودها الجنسیة فی المجتمع الذکوری، و تبین أن الکاتبات یؤکدن أکثر على عواقب الشدیدة لحرب و استناداً إلى روحهن الأنثویة، لقد عبروا بتعبیر العاطفیة عن حزنهم و تضحیاتهم فی الحرب، رووا الحرب و لم یشیدوا بها قط. تناولا کلتا کاتبتا مع استخدام التعابیر العاطفیة الأنثویة، مع ذکر لون الکلمات، و القسم و الجمل الدعاءیة و العاطفیة و الاستفهام، و الکتابة البسیطة و الجمل القصیرة موضوعات مثل انتقاد نسیان المرأة، و سلطة الذکور، و البحث عن الذات، و الحب، و ما إلى ذلک.

Keywords [العربیة]

  • الأدب الحربی
  • الکتابة النسائیة
  • هرس
  • نسیم مرعشی
  • برید بیروت
  • حنان الشیخ
Oskui, N. (2021). Analyzing the point of View of Saving the Earth by Women in the Novel “Pruning” with a Feminist Approach. Women in Culture and Art. 12(4), 567-586. (In Persian).
Aslani, M. (2005). The Interaction of Language and Gender and its Functions in Contemporary Persian Fiction. Master's Thesis of Payam-e Noor University. Supervisor: Yahya Modaresi. (In Persian).
Payande, H. (2014). Women's Stories in Contemporary Iranian Literature. Story. No. 56. 166-173. (In Persian).
Jafari, M. & Colleagues. (2022). "The Course of Using Feminine Concepts of Language in the Two Books The Last Sunday and Sheena's Daughter with a Look at Sarah Mills Linguistic Approach". Literary Research Text. 25(89), 59-85. (In Persian).
Hosseini, M. (2006). "Female Narration in Female Fiction Writing". The Book of the Month of Literature and Philosophy. Number 93, 94-101. (In Persian).
de Beauvoir, S. (2002). The Second Gender. Translated by; Qasem Sanavi. Tehran: Toos publications. (In Persian).
Rajab Bloukat, K. (2016). "Feminist Writing in Fereshte Sari's Novels". Master's Thesis of Semnan University. Faculty of Literature and Humanities. Supervisor: Abdullah Hassanzadeh. (In Persian).
Zare'e Barimi, M. (2017). "Exhibits of Femininity and Masculinity in Feminine and Masculine Writing", Contemporary Persian Literature, 8(2), 108-91. (In Persian).
Zarlaki, S. (2004). Women Against Women; Psychological Research on the Work of Alba Dess Pedes. Tehran: Farhang Kavosh. (In Persian).
Shoja'at zadeh, T. & Colleagues. (2019). "The Theory of Women's Differentiation and its Analysis in the Novel Haras Written by Nasim Marashi". Literary Criticism and Theory. 5(1), 123-142. (In Persian).
Al-Sheikh, H. (2010). Beirut Blues. Translated by; Ali Jafari. Tehran: Neshaneh. (In Persian).
Ameli Rezaei, M. (2018). "Gender and Power in the Female Discourse of Iran's Novel Writing (based on women's novels in the two decades of the 70s-80s)". Literary Criticism and Theory. 4(2), 124-99. (In Persian).
Ayari, M. (2005). Women and Women's Writing. Number. 21. (In Persian).
Fotuhi, M. (2012). Stylistics: Theories, Approaches and Methods. Second edition. Tehran: Sokhan Publications. (In Persian).
Kerachi, R. (2014). How Gender Influences Literature. Women in Culture and art (women's studies). Period 7. Number 2. 223-241. (In Persian).
Lakoff, R. (2019). Language and position of women. Translated by; Maryam Khodadadi and Yaser Pour Esmaiel. Tehran: Negah Publications. (In Persian).
Mahmoudi Bakhtiari, B., Dehghani, M. (2012). "The Relationship between Language and Gender in the Contemporary Persian Novel: A Review of six Novels". Women in Culture and Art. 5(4), 543-556. (In Persian).
Marashi, N. (2016). Haras. Tehran: Cheshme Publications. (In Persian).
Nik Manesh, M., Borji khani, M. (2012). Manifestation of Women's Writing in Da book. Linguistics. 4(8), 229-253. (In Persian).
Nikobakht, N., colleagues. (2012). "The Development Process of Female Style in the Works of Zoya Pirzad, An Analysis Based on Feminist Stylistics". Literary Criticism, 5(18), 119-152. (In Persian).